Patristic Books

Patristic Books and Articles by fr. Vassilios Bakoyiannis

Translate:


Breaking Communion with a Bishop: An Orthodox View

This article continues our previous discussion, “Is Ecumenism a Heresy?”, and examines whether breaking communion with a bishop is justified according to the teachings of the Holy Fathers and the Sacred Canons.   In other words, priests break communion with their bishops and celebrate the Divine Liturgy independently, without commemorating their bishop. They do so, claiming that their actions are supported by the Holy Fathers and the Sacred Canons. If the Holy Fathers and the Canons clearly and indisputably support this practice, then they are right to act in this way. But is this really the case?

St. Athanasius the Great says: “If a bishop or presbyter causes you to stumble, you must remove them from the assembly. It is better for you to gather in the church without them than to be cast into hell together with them, in the company of Annas and Caiaphas.”(On the interpretation of “Whoever looks at a woman with lust…” 11, P.G. 27:1369).

    Does St. Athanasius the Great, then, give the faithful the right to expel priests and bishops from the congregation? And how are they supposed to expel them? By force? Is he introducing violence into the churches? And when the faithful “succeed” in driving out their presbyters and bishops, are they to remain without presbyters and bishops? Can the Church exist without them? Therefore, St. Athanasius the Great must mean something else.

 We can find the answer in a similar teaching of St. John the Theologian. He did not even permit the faithful to greet the heretics and antichrists of his time, namely, those who did not believe in the divinity of Christ (2 John 1:9–10). But why did he do this? In order to protect those who were weak in faith. In other words, if they had been strong in faith, he would have permitted them to communicate with unbelievers and heretics.

       Something similar applies to what St. Athanasius the Great said. He had in mind the Arian presbyters and bishops of his time. In order to protect Orthodox Christians who were weak in faith, he advised them to cease praying together with Arian clergy, since there was a danger that they might be led astray.“It is better for you to gather in the church without them than to be cast into hell together with them, in the company of Annas and Caiaphas.”

   And yet, it is precisely upon these words that priests and laypeople who have broken communion with their bishops base their position. According to their own judgment, Ecumenism is a heresy, and if their bishop is an “Ecumenist,” they believe that they must separate themselves from him. “It is better for you to gather in the church without them than to be cast into hell together with them, in the company of Annas and Caiaphas.”

   Those who have broken communion with their bishops also appeal to Canon 15 of the First and Second Council of Constantinople. Let us read it carefully. “Those who separate themselves from communion with their president on account of some heresy condemned by holy Synods or Fathers, when he is publicly preaching the heresy and teaching it openly in the Church, such persons not only are not subject to the canonical penalty for walling themselves off from communion with the one called bishop before a synodal judgment, but they shall also be deemed worthy of the honor befitting the Orthodox.”

The Canon is clear. It refers to a bishop who officially preaches a heresy that has already been condemned by Councils of the Holy Fathers. Well, then, which Orthodox Council has condemned Ecumenism as a heresy?

  Let us suppose that Ecumenism has indeed been condemned as a heresy by some Council. Even so, what exactly does the Canon say in such a case? The priest ceases communion with his bishop. In other words, he remains within his diocese and his parish, continues to celebrate the Divine Liturgy, but no longer commemorates the bishop.

However, those who break communion with their bishops today do not act in this way. They leave their diocese, abandon their parish and their bishop’s jurisdiction, and celebrate the Divine Liturgy independently, as though they were a separate body.But this is heresy! “We call heretics those who, although they hold the Orthodox faith, have separated themselves from their bishops and celebrate the Divine Liturgy on their own.”(Canon 6 of the Holy Second Ecumenical Council).

 It would be good for those who oppose Ecumenism  to remember that the Eastern Church remained in communion with the Western Church, even though the latter had introduced the Filioque…

Next in this series: What Does Church Union Really Mean?”

 

 


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *