Patristic Books

Patristic Books and Articles by fr. Vassilios Bakoyiannis

Translate:


What Is the Authority of the Ecumenical Patriarchate in Orthodoxy?


On this specific issue, there are two views: one holds that the Ecumenical Patriarchate does not have authority over the entire Orthodox Church, while another maintains that the Ecumenical Patriarchate, as the first among the Orthodox Churches, cannot be considered to have the same attributes as the other Orthodox Churches.

Our personal view is that, according to the charter of the establishment (1589) of the Church of Russia as a Patriarchate—signed by all the ancient Patriarchates—the Patriarch of Moscow “shall have as head and source the Apostolic Throne of the City of Constantinople, as do the other Patriarchs.”

Since there is no living body without a living head, the Ecumenical Patriarchate, as the head of the Orthodox Body, has a vital role in the life of the Orthodox Church. Let us analyze this.

Saint John Chrysostom states: “Where all are equal, there is never peace; therefore there must be someone in authority.” (Homily 20 on Ephesians, PG 62:141)

Even among the ranks of angels there are leaders, such as the Archangels Michael and Gabriel. Thus, the concept of a “first among equals” is, in practice, often considered difficult to apply and is therefore viewed by some as problematic.

In other words, every Primate of an Orthodox Church holds the first place within his own Church. However, when the Primates of the Orthodox Churches gather together, each may occupy either the first or the last position according to the established order of precedence.

Let us consider a situation in which all the Primates of the Orthodox Church concelebrate together. Who, then, would be first in the Divine Liturgy? Can there be more than one “first,” if the first is “first among equals”? This is generally considered unlikely. One must be first, and in such a case the Ecumenical Patriarch presides, while still being understood as “first among equals.” He would determine, for example, who gives the dismissal blessing and at what point. If such a role is exercised in the Divine Liturgy, it is argued that it extends even more clearly to other ecclesiastical matters.

Rome, as the capital of the Roman Empire, functioned as a source of authority for the entire Empire. The Fathers of the Church are understood to have attributed a corresponding primacy to the Church of Rome. Accordingly, when the sacred canons refer to the Church of Rome as possessing a “primacy of honor,” this is interpreted by some as a form of primacy within the Church. (This issue will be addressed further below.) In ancient Greek usage, the term “honor” was also associated with offices and positions of authority (Plato, Apology 35B; Liddell & Scott, VII).

When Constantinople became the imperial capital, its Church came to hold the first position in the East, equal in status to the Church of Rome and sharing the same privilege of honor. “The Fathers granted primacy to Rome because it was the imperial city; for the same reason they granted equal primacy to the throne of Constantinople” (Canon 3 of the Second Ecumenical Council).

This principle is further affirmed by the Fourth Ecumenical Council (Canon 28) and the Quinisext Council (Canon 36).

Accordingly, the patriarchal throne of Constantinople is understood to hold a position of primacy within the Eastern Church. This reflects a long-standing conviction within the Eastern ecclesiastical tradition.

The provision that the Patriarch of Moscow (1589) “shall have as head and source the Apostolic Throne of the City of Constantinople, as do the other Patriarchs” is presented as evidence of this enduring canonical understanding, which persisted even after the fall of Constantinople. On this basis, the Russian Church, among others, was elevated to patriarchal status.

The Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Right of Appeal (Ekkl?ton)

Since the Church of Rome possessed the “primacy of honor,” it is also associated with the right to hear appeals, the so-called ekkl?ton. This is evidenced in the Canons of Sardica (347), which were later received in canonical tradition:

  • Canon 3: If two bishops have a dispute, they should appeal to the bishops of their province. If, after this, one party believes he has been wronged, he may appeal to the Bishop of Rome.
  • Canon 4: If a bishop is deposed by the bishops of his province and believes the deposition to be unjust, no successor is to be appointed until the Bishop of Rome has rendered judgment.
  • Canon 5: A deposed bishop may appeal to the Bishop of Rome. If Rome determines that the case should be reconsidered, it shall instruct neighboring bishops to re-examine it. If they again decide in favor of deposition, the bishop may still appeal to Rome.

On this basis, it is argued that a similar principle applies to Constantinople. Since it is regarded as possessing the same “primacy of honor” as Rome, it is understood in this interpretation to possess a corresponding right of appeal, “because it is New Rome” (Canon 3 of the Second Ecumenical Council).

For centuries, this understanding was reflected in the practice of the Orthodox Church. In this context, when Russian monks and clergy appealed in 1663 to the Patriarchates of Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem, asking whether the Ecumenical Patriarchate had the authority to adjudicate appeals beyond its jurisdiction, all four Patriarchates reportedly responded that this privilege had originally belonged to the Bishop of Rome, but after the separation of the Western Church such cases were referred to Constantinople, in accordance with the Holy Canons, which grant Constantinople similar privileges to those of Rome.

It should be noted that, in this view, the Ecumenical Patriarchate did not claim this prerogative independently, but is understood to safeguard a canonical tradition established by the Ecumenical Councils. The same responsibility is seen as extending to all Orthodox Churches. (Canon 1 of the Seventh Ecumenical Council)

Further Reading: Orthodox Cold War: Constantinople & Moscow


Comments

One response to “What Is the Authority of the Ecumenical Patriarchate in Orthodoxy?”

  1. […] Next: What Is the Authority of the Ecumenical Patriarchate in Orthodoxy? […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *